Traverse City Record-Eagle

Record-Eagle 150th Anniversary

January 24, 2009

American Indians die waiting for $21

All for $21.

Three Indians died, and hundreds of men, women and children flocked into Traverse City in late July 1910, only to wait days, some at least two weeks, for one of the 1836 treaty payments still due them.

Three Traverse City news stories stand out if you're looking for a glimpse of area American Indian life from 1900 to 1942.

This is the first -- the 1910 treaty payment bungle in Traverse City.

The U.S. Court of Claims had ruled in 1907 that the federal government still owed 5,600 Michigan Ottawa and Chippewa Indians $131,000 promised them in the 1836 treaty, according to the Evening Record.

Each adult was to receive $21.16 and each child under three $1.25, about $460 and $28 in today's dollars. The government paid about $14,000 to 700 claimants in Traverse City from July 19 to Aug. 4.

The American Indians spent about half of it in Traverse City for railroad fare, groceries, dry goods, boots, shoes and liquor "among drinking men," despite police warnings to saloon keepers and others not to sell to them, an Evening Record story noted.

The long wait, red tape and subsequent deaths were but "another example of the white man's injustice to the poor Indians," said Rep. George A. Loud, a Republican congressman from Au Sable, in town for a Spanish-American War veterans convention.

The people of Michigan and Traverse City also came under fire.

"There is more prejudice against these people in Michigan than in any state we have been in, and it is senseless," Charles Dickson, payment agent for the federal Office of Indian Affairs, told the Evening Record. "People in Traverse City act as though they had never seen an Indian before."

Only 35 people a day could be processed under federal rules for verifying American Indian identities against treaty-related enrollment records that had been created two years before for 5,600 Ottawa and Chippewa Indians in Michigan. Index cards with their names were not even alphabetized.

Meanwhile, American Indians from Petoskey, Northport and even Saginaw flocked to Traverse City, though Dickson would visit those places later.

The city's boarding houses were full. The city also was hosting the veterans convention and a very successful "Traverse City Day" that attracted an estimated 5,000 people from outlying areas.

Police Chief Charles Ashton found vacant rooms in a downtown building for mothers "too weary to stand," who crowded into his office with their babies and small children. All had to sleep on bare floors. A large canvas was stretched across the beach for others who slept on the sand with no other covering than the canopy, the Evening Record reported July 21.

Loud's letter to Robert G. Valentine, Office of Indian Affairs commissioner in Washington, criticized the agency for gross mismanagement and outrageous treatment of American Indians.

"It is impossible to conceive of a body of white people submitting to the treatment as have been involved in this payment of the just dues to these poor Indians. If anyone wished to outrage these poor people, nothing more diabolical in its unfairness and injustice could possibly be conceived," he wrote.

Of the three men who died, two were run over by a train, "their bodies cut to fragments," Loud wrote. The third fell on stone steps in front of the bank while waiting for his payment. Their lives "should rest upon the consciences of the office in Washington who planned this un-businesslike method of payment."

Loud said his last impression of Traverse City as his 6:30 a.m. train pulled away was an American Indian woman sitting on the steps of a store near the payment office, waiting for it to reopen.

"It was not a pleasant picture," he said.

-- Loraine Anderson

Text Only
  • After looking back, we look to the future

    In this last installment of the Record-Eagle's year-long 150th Anniversary History Project series, native son Bill Milliken ponders the future, including the question: What will the Traverse City area be like in 2159?

    Continued ...
    Nov 8, 2009 7:14 am 9 Photos
  • Derek Bailey: Cooperation is key

    I am excited and optimistic in thinking about my predictions for the area and Grand Traverse Band of Ottawa and Chippewa Indians for the next 150 years. Clearly, we live in one of the most beautiful areas of Mother Earth. The GTB Tribal Nation has grown exponentially as an area and tribe over the last 29 years. We must now sustain and channel that growth.

    Continued ...
    Nov 8, 2009 7:12 am 1 Photo
  • George McManus: Manage resources

    The Grand Traverse Region is blessed with abundant renewable natural resources, which properly managed, will remain for the next 150 years and beyond. The community of the future depends on what direction the citizenry and leadership decide to take and external influences over which they have no control.

    Continued ...
    Nov 8, 2009 7:11 am 1 Photo
  • Marsha Smith: Listen to each other

    The Grand Vision has shown me that the people of this region love it here and have a commitment to building a better future. We care about what happens here and we care about the future. My main concern is that we sometimes forget about all things we hold in common and focus more on what keeps us apart.

    Continued ...
    Nov 8, 2009 7:11 am 1 Photo
  • Joe VanderMeulen: Plan for six generations

    We need to look forward across six or more generations of people to see 150 years into the future. What wonderful changes there may be, if we choose wisely, just get lucky, or some of both. Of course, we face many threats to our security and survival. The risks of deadly pandemics, global climate change and unimaginable wars are real.

    Continued ...
    Nov 8, 2009 7:10 am 1 Photo
  • November 2, 2009
  • Women helped build Traverse City

    Women helped build Traverse City's library system, schools and hospital. They lobbied for clean water and clean streets. They were concerned about the needy, child labor, reforestation, international peace and the right of women to vote. They did this largely through two local women's clubs -- the Ladies Library Association and the Traverse City Woman's Club.

    Continued ...
    Nov 2, 2009 6:17 am 4 Photos
  • TC's early women leaders

    Thirteen women who influenced early Traverse City are profiled.

    Continued ...
    Nov 2, 2009 6:15 am
  • October 31, 2009
  • TC history exhibit visits TADL

    The Record-Eagle's traveling exhibit of Traverse City and newspaper history will be on display throughout November at the Traverse Area District Library on Woodmere.

    Continued ...
    Oct 31, 2009 9:30 pm
  • October 19, 2009
  • Loraine Anderson: TC's 1925 earthquake

    Earthquakes are rare in Michigan, but Traverse City residents definitely felt the earth move beneath their feet and watched electric ceiling lights sway overhead on Feb. 28, 1925. "EARTHQUAKE HERE FIRST EVER FELT: Dishes Rattle, Chairs Rock, Smokers 'Swear Off' and People in High Places Come Down," Record-Eagle headlines shouted after tremors rattled the city at 8:27 p.m. that Saturday night.

    Continued ...
    Oct 19, 2009 7:00 am 1 Photo
  • October 5, 2009
  • Water Wars: Advocating for 'public trust'

    It was a busy summer on the water front for Great Lakes advocates in what environmentalists and others are calling "The Water Wars."

    Continued ...
    Oct 5, 2009 6:18 am 3 Photos
  • October 3, 2009
  • R-E editorial decries water diversion

    Record-Eagle concern about Great Lakes water diversion dates to the early 1900s, including a Jan. 14, 1925, editorial about the U.S. governments challenge of Chicagos right to divert Lake Michigan water without consulting its neighbors.

    Continued ...
    Oct 3, 2009 9:55 pm
  • Summary of summer Great Lakes water issues

    Great Lakes water issues this summer included the following.

    Continued ...
    Oct 3, 2009 9:55 pm
  • September 28, 2009
  • 150 Years: Bay served as sewer, water supply

    The Boardman River in Traverse City wasn't a pretty sight at the turn of the last century. It was a city sewer, and it flowed into West Bay, the source of the city's water supply.

    Continued ...
    Sep 28, 2009 7:18 am 7 Photos
  • August 10, 2009
  • 150 Years: Cartographer maps settlements

    Helen Hornbeck Tanner, a Beulah summer resident and historian of Great Lakes American Indians and cartography, created a new historical map of the Grand Traverse region that traces early American Indian and white settlement.

    Continued ...
    Aug 10, 2009 6:39 am 2 Photos
  • July 27, 2009
  • Loraine Anderson: Tracking Titus

    Harold Titus has been one of my favorite Traverse City historical characters since I read "Timber," his 1922 novel, last year. He intrigues me for many reasons. Part of his mystery is that he is virtually unknown today. He is "new" local history.

    Continued ...
    Jul 27, 2009 8:06 am 1 Photo