Traverse City Record-Eagle

Residents caught in grip of failing state, national economies

December 15, 2008

Fixed-income seniors struggle with budgets

TRAVERSE CITY -- There was a time when Pat and Bob Pierce had a money cushion, a few dollars left over once the bills were stamped and sent.

Those days are gone. So too is eating out. And traveling. And purchases that aren't absolutely necessary.

"We used to be able to save a little bit each month. There's nothing to save anymore," said Pat Pierce, 74. "Some months, it's right down even ... I don't like that."

The Pierces, married for 55 years, live in a Garfield Township mobile home park. They are among the region's senior population who have serious worries about rising prices, declining investments and increasingly tumultuous economic times.

The couple exists on Social Security benefits and Bob's pension from Chrysler, so the much-publicized plight of the Big Three automakers only adds to their concern.

"It may not be a huge pension, but it is what keeps us here where we're at right now," Pat said. "I would say possibly if he lost his pension we might eventually lose our home."

A shared problem

The Pierces aren't alone, and sometimes kinship helps. Organizations like the Traverse City Senior Center, where both of them volunteer each week, provides resources and a sounding board.

"Being with the senior center, we've got friends in there in the same situation," Bob said. "We can talk about it and be honest with each other and try to lift each other's spirits up."

But because seniors are cutting back on travel and other expenses, the center has seen a decrease in patrons as the economy soured, Director Lori Wells said.

"If anything, I think people are staying home even more, which really bothers me," she said.

Wells said those who stop by mention the same concerns: reduced or eliminated pensions, high heating and food costs and reduced retirement investments. Some have to keep working longer than planned. Others have to go back to work.

It's difficult to quantify how many of the region's seniors are struggling financially, said Dee Wilkinson, spokeswoman for the 10-county Area Agency on Aging of Northwest Michigan. But more seniors need help, she said, and some are reaching out for the first time.

"(We get) apologetic calls, people say 'I never thought I'd be here," she said. "Every call is a tough call to make."

The Grand Traverse County Commission on Aging has seen a sharp increase in seniors who take advantage of a program that provides a one-time payment up to $500 for emergency home repairs, heating costs or other expenses.

In 2006, 96 such payments were made, said commission Director Georgia Durga. But nearly 150 have been made through November of this year. Officials expect to see the number rise throughout December.

"They are starting to pour in now that it's getting colder," Durga said.

The Goodwill Inn, which houses homeless, hasn't seen a noticeable overall increase in seniors in recent months, Director Lois Lannin said. But they have noticed a jump in people older than 75, she said, a relatively uncommon occurrence in previous years.

"When they do come, it's like everybody else," Lannin said. "They have a bunch of problems."

The number of Grand Traverse County residents 65 and older living below the poverty level jumped from 2.6 percent in 2006 to 4.5 percent in 2007, according to United States Census data. But figures for both years were significantly lower than those for residents ages 18-64, which ranged up to 9.6 percent.

Jim Rowlett, chair of the Traverse City-based Poverty Reduction Initiative, said seniors are somewhat cushioned because many already are out of the turbulent workforce.

"They're affected, but I think they're affected less than the general population," he said.

Making changes

Bob Pierce retired from Chrysler in 1982 after more than 30 years as a die maker. The thought of having to go back to work has crossed his wife Pat's mind, she said.

Or she could make and sell crafts, though she knows that likely won't bring in enough to pay the bills.

Plummeting gas prices eased some of the pain, but those savings are offset by a cold, early winter and seemingly ever-rising heating costs. They're already preparing to make some adjustments.

"If we do have a really cold winter, what I'll do is turn the heat down and just have a blanket on me," Pat said.

They've also taken advantage of "Angel Food," a program run through their church that gives them $70 worth of groceries a week for about $30.

"It's made a big difference in our grocery bill, quite a bit," Pat said.

Traverse City resident Nancy Goerlich, 72, also needed to shave her grocery bill. Last week she pushed a cart through Save-A-Lot on Garfield Avenue, a grocery stop she now usually chooses over pricier stores.

"It's the expense of everything, and the groceries," she said. "That's why I'm in this store ... it's more economical."

Goerlich's husband Larry owns a sign shop. He always thought he'd be at least semi-retired a long time ago, she said, but the couple just can't afford it.

"(Larry) would be taking a little more time off here and there," she said.

For seniors, many of whom have children, economic worries extend far beyond themselves. Their kids have grown up and moved out, but the parental instinct never fades.

"Our kids, that's who I'm scared for," said Mary Franklin, 70, as she shopped at the Salvation Army Thrift Store on South Airport Road. "So far my kids are okay, but they're on the brink, I feel."

The Pierces can relate. They have a daughter and son-in-law who lost their jobs and eventually lost their home. They gave support, but eventually had to look out for their own finances.

"We helped them as long as we could, but we had nothing left to give," Pat said. "That was hard."

For now, the Pierces will try to maintain a positive outlook, they said. They know other seniors who are in worse shape. They lean on their spirituality and give thanks for what they have.

"We are strong Christian people, and we have faith that we're going to be taken care of no matter what situation comes up," Bob said. "That's the only thing I can look for, because I don't know what the future's going to be. Nobody does."

Coming Tuesday: Cobbling together a living

Text Only
  • Locals work multiple jobs making ends meet

    Elyse Boyd darts between tables and the cook's grill, delivers hot plates of breakfast to hungry diners, then pauses to take a sip of Mountain Dew behind the counter. It's a busy life for Boyd, 21, who works four jobs to help support her family, including her husband and 3-year-old daughter.

    Continued ...
    Dec 16, 2008 10:08 am 2 Photos
  • Fighting to stay afloat during recession

    Aza Drielts-Davis would work 60 hours a week if she could. But no one's offering that many hours these days, so she logs about 40 between shifts at Admiral Discount Tobacco and as a receptionist at Advanced Computer Solutions in Traverse City.

    Continued ...
    Dec 14, 2008 10:31 am 2 Photos
  • Mother can't work, so children step up

    Teenagers Alisha and Nicole Bowles are expert bargain hunters; they frequently clip coupons and shop at discount retailers and secondhand stores for everything from clothing to Christmas gifts. "Young girls at their age want their own money," their mother, Barb Vickers, said. "But they want to help."

    Continued ...
    Updated Dec 14, 2008 10:11 am 2 Photos
  • School is 'first line of defense'

    Children are not immune to the effects of an economic recession, even when parents try to shield them from discussions on family finances, an elementary school social worker said.

    Continued ...
    Updated Dec 14, 2008 10:11 am
  • Sunday, August 24, 2008
  • Families stretch back-to-school dollars

    Instead of extras, Heather Pollington's daughters will return to school next week with just the basics. Some new supplies, a pair of shoes, jeans and a few shirts. There isn't room for much else.

    Continued ...
    Aug 24, 2008 9:52 am 1 Photo
  • Tuesday, July 1, 2008
  • Housing slump, economy keeps shelter busy

    Ken Homa can see the region's tattered economy wearing on the people his agency tries to assist during tough times.

    Continued ...
    Jul 1, 2008 10:02 am
  • Homeless dream of better lives

    Sometimes she wakes in the middle of the night and worries she's not a good mother. She listens as her children sleep nearby, their rhythmic breathing a small comfort, a hedge against anxiety and fear that threaten to overwhelm her. She listens to the night sounds so close, just outside the thin walls of a tent she and her children -- Mary, 17, Edward, 12, and Aimee, 4 -- call home.

    Continued ...
    Jul 1, 2008 9:53 am 7 Photos
  • Monday, June 30, 2008
  • Business 'doing whatever we can'

    The coolers inside John Rosa's liquor store and pizzeria are half empty. It's too expensive to restock. Outside, gas pumps are shut off, and stand as weathered remnants of a bygone era. For decades, Rosa's family made a living selling gas and repairing cars. That was then.

    Continued ...
    Jun 30, 2008 10:02 am 2 Photos
  • <a href="http://photos.record-eagle.com/gallery/5292540_BfnGM">Photo Story: Getting by at Bud's</a>

    Continued ...
    Jun 30, 2008 10:02 am 1 Photo
  • Teens struggle to find summer work

    Leah Ferguson worked as a dishwasher at a local American Legion Post, then for a catering business and finally made restaurant stops at Mustard's and Trattoria Stella in Traverse City. The recent Traverse City Central grad has plenty of service industry experience, but now struggles to find a job.

    Continued ...
    Jun 30, 2008 10:01 am 2 Photos
  • More people leaving the state

    Bob Thalman is considering leaving Michigan to begin his career. He graduated in May from Cedarville University in Ohio with a degree in English and a passion for libraries. He has worked at the Traverse Area District Library since 2002, a job he holds today. But Thalman, 22, said Ohio is more "optimistic" than Michigan about library careers.

    Continued ...
    Jun 30, 2008 10:00 am 1 Photo
  • Sunday, June 29, 2008
  • Hard times force residents to change ways

    This story begins a three-day Record-Eagle series examines the lives of those caught in the grip of the failing state and national economies, and offers snapshot examples of how your friends, family, neighbors, and communities cope during bad times.

    Continued ...
    Jun 29, 2008 11:09 am 3 Photos
  • Pawn shops thrive in lean times

    Logan Drake's sweaty hair clung to his forehead as his mother Kristine lifted the toddler from their car parked near Ace Buyers pawn shop. Logan's father, Shawn, popped the trunk and retrieved a rifle case. Then the family shuffled into Ace Buyers, and minutes later the Buckley clan had what they came for: money for food and gas for another week.

    Continued ...
    Jun 29, 2008 11:08 am 2 Photos
  • Times are tough in tiny town of Honor

    A neighbor's worn-out swing set was headed for the dump before Becky Link salvaged it for her 4-year-old daughter, Riley. Link, of Honor, couldn't afford such a luxury. She makes $7.50 an hour at JC Penny in Traverse City, but after spending $10 in gas to get there and $20 for daycare, she leaves with only $30 after each eight-hour shift.

    Continued ...
    Jun 29, 2008 11:08 am 3 Photos
  • Increased poaching for food 'possible'

    One northern Michigan man acknowledges he's guilty of the crime of poaching. But he said he illegally killed a deer only because of his lousy financial situation. "It's feeding your family," he said.

    Continued ...
    Jun 29, 2008 11:08 am
  • Some put away keys, turn to buses, scooters

    Jan Nickerson doesn't mind walking to the Kingsley post office each day to make her public transit bus connection. The money she saves by riding instead of driving steered her to the bus nearly two years ago.

    Continued ...
    Jun 29, 2008 11:08 am
  • Extra stops worth it to save on meal money

    Madge Smith and her friend Barb Allen wheeled into the parking lot at Purchases Sales Company in Gaylord for just one thing: a gallon of milk. The friends from Waters stop by the wholesale milk and ice cream distributing company each week for bargains on dairy products.

    Continued ...
    Jun 29, 2008 11:07 am 1 Photo
  • BATA driver: 'I've been blessed'

    Doris Morgan may have a lot on her plate, but she's buoyed by the "angels on my shoulders." Morgan, 53, drives a bus for the Bay Area Transportation Authority and, like many other northern Michigan residents, feels the acute pinch of the state's economic woes. She works full time, but at $12 per hour struggles to make a decent living. She's not complaining, though.

    Continued ...
    Jun 29, 2008 11:07 am
  • Hundreds in region face foreclosure

    Susan Forcier loved the 10-acre, Hayes Township spread she called home for nearly five years. Over the past year she watched variable interest rates push her house payment to $1,500 a month, almost triple the previous payment, and late fees and penalties pulled her under.

    Continued ...
    Jun 29, 2008 11:06 am 2 Photos