Traverse City Record-Eagle

Michigan

October 8, 2011

Offshore wind legislation stymied

A year after state recommendation, efforts becalmed

By JACOB KANCLERZ Special to the Record-Eagle

LANSING — A year ago state energy experts recommended developing offshore wind energy in the Great Lakes, but lawmakers have not passed legislation needed to implement it.

The Michigan Great Lakes Wind Council recommended to former Gov. Jennifer Granholm sites where offshore wind turbines would work best and legislation to regulate the industry. A new administration and a year later, state agencies and supportive groups are still working on bills to aid its development.

Offshore wind turbines can produce more energy than those on land and could significantly reduce the need to buy out-of-state fuel, said James Clift, policy director for the Michigan Environmental Council. Clift was part of the governor-appointed Great Lakes Wind Council, formed in 2009.

The council set criteria for desirable areas for offshore wind development and was then given the go-ahead by Granholm to propose locations and legislation.

An offshore wind bill introduced last legislative session didn't advance, said Frank Ruswick, deputy director of the Office of the Great Lakes. His agency is refining that bill to re-introduce this session, but has not found a legislator to sponsor it.

The bill will set up a framework for leasing and developing underwater land for offshore wind, since none exists, said Mike Berkowitz, chapter organizer for Michigan's Sierra Club. His organization is working with the Office of the Great Lakes to prepare the legislation to debut later this fall or early spring.

A bill introduced last spring seeks to prohibit offshore wind in the Great Lakes. Rep. Ray Franz, R-Onekama, is the primary sponsor of that bill, which is in the House Energy and Technology Committee.

"We don't believe the Great Lakes should be industrialized," said Jennifer Smeltzer, the legislative director for Franz. "Industrialized wind turbines in the Great Lakes affects shipping, it affects fishing."

The bill has not been scheduled for a hearing. Berkowitz said it is going nowhere because it contains misconceptions about offshore wind, including concerns over interrupting shipping lanes and fish habitats and killing of birds and bats. Berkowitz said the Great Lakes Wind Council accounted for these issues in selecting the sites suitable for offshore wind development.

"If we just follow the Great Lakes Wind council recommendations, we wouldn't have any issues with any of these things, these migratory patterns or shipping lanes or anything like that," he said.

The council selected five areas most suitable for offshore wind development: southern Lake Michigan near Berrien County, northern Lake Michigan near Delta County, central Lake Superior near Alger County, central Lake Huron near Saginaw Bay and southern Lake Huron near Sanilac County.

Berkowitz said he's seen some bipartisan support for offshore wind, but the House and Senate Committees on Energy and Technology haven't scheduled anything regarding offshore wind yet.

The Senate committee is reviewing progress on the 2008 law requiring Michigan to generate 10 percent of its energy via renewable sources by 2015. Offshore wind development could be a factor in meeting that goal, said Greg Moore, the legislative director for Sen. Mike Nofs, R-Battle Creek, chair of the committee.

Jacob Kanclerz writes for Michigan State University's Capital News Service.

Text Only